Article by Udi Tirosh (April 30, 2015)
NOT ALL LED PANELS ARE MADE EQUAL. HERE’S HOW TO TELL THE DIFFERENCE.
This article talks about LEDs and CRI. You see not all LEDs were created equal. Most of the time when we talk about LEDs we talk brightness and color temperature, and that makes sense as those are easily measured and have great impact on our photos.
One thing that we often overlook is CRI. And what is CRI you ask? Well CRI stands for Color rendering index and it the number that has the bigger impact on the quality of light.
Let me explain.
You already know that not all whites are created equal. A florescent light is not the same as incandescent light, and those are not the same as an LED light.
WHY CRI MATTERS?
Because white is actually made of combining all the colors in the spectrum.
The sun is a perfect example, if you put the sunlight through a prism (as Pink Floyd showed us with the awesomeDark Side of The Moon) you get all the colors of the rainbow.
This is not the case with all lights.
Some lights, like LED lights have more of one color and none of the other. The quality of the mix is measured with CRI.
We are going to use a handy device called a Spectrometer – the one that we are using for these test is calledLighting Passport from Allied Scientific Pro. It is a small boxy device that provides incredibly accurate results and we absolutely fell in love with it. We were also very surprised with some of the results.
Let’s look at the sky. as we can see it has all color components in roughly similar quantities, with a slight shift to the blue as the skies are blue because of the scattering effect.
Now Let’s look at a cheap LED bulb. As we can see, there is a huge blue pike and a high green spike but almost no red.
Another way to look at this is by using RA tests. RA tests test the how the light will render a certain color, with colors like red and green, but also colors like Caucasian and Asian skin tones.
Let’s compare the RA test results of the sun and our DIY built LED panel. Can you guess which is which?
As we can see R9 which is strong RED is absent completely from the cheap LED panel
Now, any CRI below 8o is not really suitable for photography and anything under 85 is quite marginal. Now for the full results
WE TESTED SEVERAL LIGHTS:
The Cheaper LEDs that we used can are around 70-75. This is ok if you are doing black and white or if you don’t really care about color rendering.
The light bulb measured at 71, the DIY panel at 73 and the non name panel at 76.
The best light came from the Amaran panels with the older AL528 coming at 87 CRI and the newer HR672 coming in at astounding 96.